Happiness and Keeping Ahead of the Joneses


Imagine that the Internal Revenue Service in your country claimed that you owe $1000 plus in tax arrears.

You dispute this, and you challenge the tax people in court, but the court rules that they're right. Especially if you're a person of substantial means, you'd pay up with a shrug of the shoulders. "Too bad," you'll comfort yourself, "you can't win all the time!" and you'll put the matter out of your mind fairly quickly.

Now let's assume that instead of the government, an acquaintance, or even a good friend, alleges that you're in his debt, for whatever reason, for the same sum of money.

Again, you go to court.

Your alleged creditor pleads his case, you plead yours. Eventually, the judge decides in his favor, and even explains to you very patiently why the money rightfully belongs to your opponent.

How do you react to your loss now?

Probably, even if you're very wealthy, you're not about to shrug it off so quickly this time!

Why not? Because somebody else is gaining at your expense! If there's anything worse than a property loss, it's an Ego loss. Now, for most of us, that's really a heavy burden to bear!

What brings this kind of scenario to mind is some recent research into an interesting social paradox. Over the past 50 or 60 years, developed countries have been growing progressively richer, but their people, on the whole, don't seem to have become much happier.

Yes, more rich people, proportionately speaking, claim to be happier at any given time than do poorer people. This should lead you to the conclusion that as incomes rise and a country as a whole grows richer, both the relatively rich and the relatively poor would become happier.

But this isn't the case, apparently. It may still be axiomatic that an individual who becomes richer becomes happier, or at least claims to be. But when society as a whole gets wealthier, nobody seems more pleased with their lot. Why?

In a series of lectures at the London School of Economics this year, Richard Layard, an economics professor at the School, reviewed the evidence from several disciplines in an attempt to solve this paradox.

The real problem, he suggests, is that people are in the habit of comparing their lot with others. If I have a million but you have two million, I have to be feeling miserable. My million is almost worthless to me.





Related News



Happiness may protect against cancer - The Australian

Health Newstrack

Happiness may protect against cancer
The Australian, Australia -Aug 25, 2008
After questioning more than 600 women – include 255 breast cancer patients – about life experiences, happiness and depression, researchers found optimists ...
Research: Severe life events raise breast cancer riskXinhua
Happiness'can cut breast cancer risk by a quarter'Hindu Business Line
Happiness may protect against breast cancer, study suggestsTelegraph.co.uk
Jerusalem Post - Irish Health
all 163 news articles

the world is becoming a happier place - guardian.co.uk

the world is becoming a happier place
guardian.co.uk, UK -6 hours ago
The researchers who compiled the data believe increasing levels of happiness were not picked up until now because studies have tended to focus on rich ...
Why the world is a happier placeNew Scientist (subscription)
all 2 news articles

Hooning halts honeymoon happiness - Cranbourne News

Cranbourne News

Hooning halts honeymoon happiness
Cranbourne News, Australia -7 hours ago
The lovebirds were married in their backyard two weeks ago, and Friday night’s incident has put an abrupt end to their honeymoon happiness. ...

Despite Down Economy, Workers’ Spirits Still Up, Says Annual Job ... - Business Wire (press release)

Despite Down Economy, Workers’ Spirits Still Up, Says Annual Job ...
Business Wire (press release), CA -10 hours ago
While worker happiness is trending upwards slightly, the US labor force is expressing marked concern over the nation’s economy. ...
High energy prices getting you down? At least you’re workingBizjournals.com
all 10 news articles

A Salmon's Tale: Why Happiness Beats Going Belly Up - Area Developer

A Salmon's Tale: Why Happiness Beats Going Belly Up
Area Developer, CA -8 hours ago
Americans have more material possessions to show for the effort, but at the same time studies show a diminishing level of "happiness. ...

Sahara Centre spreads light of happiness this Ramadan - AME Info

AME Info

Sahara Centre spreads light of happiness this Ramadan
AME Info, United Arab Emirates -13 hours ago
Sahara Centre's 'Spreading the light of happiness' campaign marks the beginning of a noble initiative during the Holy Month. ...


Sorry, Germaine, but for most families, happiness remains vaguely ... - Times Online

Sorry, Germaine, but for most families, happiness remains vaguely ...
Times Online, UK -Aug 26, 2008
For most families, happiness remains vaguely house-shaped. The abyss of repossessions and negative equity we are now in is deplorable: and after watching ...

Fisher: Happiness is an empty nest - San Jose Mercury News

Fisher: Happiness is an empty nest
San Jose Mercury News,  USA -Aug 26, 2008
By Patty Fisher I fingered the cell phone in my pocket, wondering if it was ever going to ring. It had been more than 40 hours since we'd hugged our younger ...

Why happiness is a postcode lottery - Independent

Times Online

Why happiness is a postcode lottery
Independent, UK -56 minutes ago
It is the conclusion of a survey attempting to measure happiness across the country, not by focusing on income, health and quality of life in a given area, ...
Rainy Manchester may need defending, but it scores highly in ...Times Online
Auld Reekie is the most miserable place to live in BritainTimes Online
all 3 news articles

Why our happiness is taking a dive - The Canberra Times

Why our happiness is taking a dive
The Canberra Times, Australia -3 hours ago
BY MICHAEL RUFFLES For the first time in seven years men are feeling better than women, but overall happiness is taking a dive as inflation hits the hip ...
Women's wellbeing linked to CPI: surveyThe Age
Women aren't as upbeat as menSydney Morning Herald
Rising prices to blame for miseryAdelaidenow
The Age
all 152 news articles